The MECE (Mutually Exclusive, Collectively Exhaustive) principle is essential for breaking down complex problems into clear, non-overlapping categories that cover the entire scope of an issue. Below are ten examples of MECE breakdowns, each followed by a discussion on why it is MECE, what might be improved, and an alternative approach to achieving a more refined MECE segmentation.
Example 1: Revenue Streams
Original Breakdown:
- Product Revenue
- Service Revenue
- Other Income (e.g., licensing, royalties)
Why it is MECE: Each revenue category is clearly distinct, with no overlap between revenue generated by selling products, providing services, or earning from ancillary income. Together, they aim to capture all sources of revenue.
What might be improved: The “Other Income” category can be too broad, potentially mixing different types of income that may benefit from further subdivisions.
Alternative Approach: Split “Other Income” into more specific categories, such as Licensing Revenue and Royalty Revenue, ensuring that each source is distinct and covers the full spectrum of non-core revenue.
Example 2: Market Segmentation
Original Breakdown:
- Demographic Segmentation
- Psychographic Segmentation
- Behavioral Segmentation
Why it is MECE: These three segmentation methods are mutually exclusive because each focuses on different characteristics of customers, and collectively they encompass the broad range of consumer attributes.
What might be improved: Overlap can sometimes occur between psychographic and behavioral factors; customer behavior might be influenced by their lifestyle, creating ambiguity.
Alternative Approach: Consider refining the categories into Demographic, Geographic, and Behavioral/Psychographic Combined segmentation if the data shows significant interplay between lifestyle and behavior.
Example 3: Product Lifecycle Stages
Original Breakdown:
- Introduction
- Growth
- Maturity
- Decline
Why it is MECE: Each stage represents a unique phase in a product’s lifecycle, with clear and distinct characteristics that do not overlap, covering the entire lifespan of a product.
What might be improved: In practice, some products may experience an extended “Maturity” phase where subtle shifts are not captured by this four-stage model.
Alternative Approach: Add a transitional phase (e.g., “Saturation”) to capture the nuances between Growth and Decline, ensuring all market conditions are addressed without overlap.
Example 4: Cost Structure Analysis
Original Breakdown:
- Fixed Costs
- Variable Costs
- Semi-Variable Costs
Why it is MECE: This categorization clearly separates costs into those that remain constant, those that change with production volume, and those that have both fixed and variable components, covering the entire cost structure.
What might be improved: The category of semi-variable costs can be ambiguous if not defined precisely, leading to potential misclassification.
Alternative Approach: Define specific thresholds for what constitutes a semi-variable cost or break it down further into two sub-categories based on percentage variability, ensuring clearer boundaries.
Example 5: Digital Marketing Channels
Original Breakdown:
- Social Media Marketing
- Search Engine Marketing (SEM)
- Email Marketing
- Affiliate Marketing
Why it is MECE: Each channel is distinct and targets a different method of reaching customers, and together they cover the main digital avenues for marketing.
What might be improved: Some overlap may exist between social media and affiliate marketing, as influencers on social platforms often drive affiliate traffic.
Alternative Approach: Consider combining social media and affiliate marketing into a single category if the strategies and metrics used overlap significantly, then add a separate category for emerging digital channels such as mobile app advertising.
Example 6: Organizational Structure Analysis
Original Breakdown:
- Functional Structure
- Divisional Structure
- Matrix Structure
Why it is MECE: These categories are distinct ways to organize a company; a business typically adopts one primary structure, and together these options encompass most organizational designs.
What might be improved: In some modern organizations, hybrid structures can blur the lines between these traditional categories.
Alternative Approach: Introduce a fourth category—Hybrid Structures—to capture organizations that blend elements from multiple structures, ensuring complete coverage without forcing a misclassification.
Example 7: Customer Support Channels
Original Breakdown:
- Phone Support
- Email Support
- Live Chat Support
- Social Media Support
Why it is MECE: Each support channel is a distinct method of communication with customers, and together they cover all major avenues for customer service.
What might be improved: There may be emerging support channels (like AI chatbots) that aren’t explicitly covered in this list.
Alternative Approach: Add a category for Automated/AI Support if the organization employs these methods, ensuring the list remains current and exhaustive.
Example 8: Project Management Phases
Original Breakdown:
- Initiation
- Planning
- Execution
- Closure
Why it is MECE: These four phases represent a widely recognized lifecycle in project management. Each phase is distinct, and together they cover every stage of a project from start to finish.
What might be improved: Some projects might benefit from a dedicated monitoring phase between execution and closure to address performance issues in real time.
Alternative Approach: Consider adding a Monitoring and Controlling phase, which can help ensure that projects stay on track and adjustments are made before final closure.
Example 9: Sales Funnel Segmentation
Original Breakdown:
- Awareness
- Consideration
- Decision
- Retention
Why it is MECE: The sales funnel stages are distinct steps in the customer journey, and together they capture every stage from the initial introduction of a product to long-term customer engagement.
What might be improved: In practice, the “Consideration” stage can sometimes overlap with both “Awareness” and “Decision” if not clearly defined.
Alternative Approach: Refine the stages by incorporating a sub-stage within “Consideration” (for example, separating “Interest” from “Evaluation”), which can clarify transitions between initial awareness and final decision-making.
Example 10: Strategic Business Initiatives
Original Breakdown:
- Growth Initiatives
- Efficiency Initiatives
- Innovation Initiatives
- Risk Management Initiatives
Why it is MECE: Each initiative focuses on a distinct strategic area—whether it’s driving revenue growth, improving operational efficiency, fostering innovation, or managing risks. Together, they capture the full spectrum of strategic priorities.
What might be improved: The “Innovation Initiatives” category may sometimes overlap with “Growth Initiatives” if innovation is primarily aimed at revenue generation.
Alternative Approach: Consider separating innovation into two categories: one focused on Product/Service Innovation and another on Process Innovation, to ensure that each strategic area is clearly defined and there is no overlap.
Want more examples?
You can check out the social media examples and others
Do you have a toolkit for business problem solving? I created Think Like a Strategy Consultant as an online course to make the tools of strategy consultants accessible to driven professionals, executives, and consultants. This course teaches you how to synthesize information into compelling insights, structure your information in ways that help you solve problems, and develop presentations that resonate at the C-Level. Click here to learn more or if you are interested in getting started now.
